New Internationalist

PHOTO ESSAY: For Eritrean migrants, there is more dignity in death

Web exclusive

Tim Baster and Isabelle Merminod capture the painful goodbyes of the survivors of the recent Lampedusa tragedy and the victims’ families.

On 3 October, a 17 metre long smuggler’s boat sank off the Italian island of Lampedusa. At around 3am around 550 people, mostly Eritreans, fought for their lives in the sea. Officials have given slightly differing figures, but some 370 bodies have now been recovered while 156 survived the sinking.

Approximately 16,000 people died on the EU border from 1998 to 2012 according to UN Special Rapporteur on the Human Rights of Migrants, François Crépeau.

But EU politicians speak of further tightening border control as if turning irregular migration into a security issue will stop people fleeing from repression.

Above: Italian politicians spoke of national funerals and even the grant of posthumous citizenship. But two weeks later, there is only silence. The coffins at the port of Lampedusa are lifted onto the deck of the Italian naval vessel, the Libra, for their next journey to Sicily. Many bodies have still not been identified by relatives or survivors.

Above: In the presence of international journalists, survivors recount the sinking of their decrepit boat that sailed from Libya. Some had spent two months in a Libyan safe house waiting for the smuggler’s boat to leave for Italy, their next destination. They lost friends and relatives. They knew the children. 370 lost their life on this journey; 156 have to continue theirs.

Above: Mostly from Europe, relatives come to identify their loved ones. They spend hours in the Carabineri’s (Italian military police) office in front of hundreds of photos of bodies or looking at photos of objects and jewellery that might have belonged to their loved ones. Occasionally a coffin would be lowered to the quay to allow relatives to mourn. Although time was limited, they were able to mourn in front of a named coffin not a number.

Above: As the children’s coffins are carried to the naval vessel by survivors, soldiers and police stand to attention in an honour guard on either side. But when the children lived they were forced to run Europe’s tight border controls in a dangerous boat with no navigation instruments.

Above: After spending some time by the side of a coffin, an Eritrean relative looks on, distraught. Italian Prime Minister Enrico Letta has said that the victims are now ‘Italian citizens’. But were EU immigration polices based on human rights, not xenophobia and hatred, these 370 people might not have taken a dangerous boat to arrive in Italy and might still be alive.

Above: The white coffins for the eight children found in the wreckage of the boat at Lampedusa’s shore are brought back together with the other coffins and will be transported to Sicily. A teddy bear – a gift from Italian children – was placed on top of each coffin.

Above: Christians and Muslims pray together remembering the dead in a final farewell before letting the boat make its journey to Sicily. Relatives and survivors do not know where the bodies will go next.* The Eritrean government has asked for the repatriation of the bodies to Eritrea.

Above: These migrants are not the first to have died near the coast of Lampedusa, and tragically, are unlikely to be the last. In April, the UN Special Rapporteur on the Human Rights of Migrants, François Crépeau condemned the border control policies of the European Union and the ‘political discourse’ which turns irregular migration into a ‘security problem.’

He believes that ‘repression of irregular migration is counterproductive, as it drives migrants further underground, thereby empowering smuggling rings, and creating conditions of alienation and marginalization that foster human rights violations.’

Will European leaders listen?

All photographs are the copyright of Tim Baster and Isabelle Merminod.

*It is now known that the bodies are being buried in cemeteries in Sicily.

Comments on PHOTO ESSAY: For Eritrean migrants, there is more dignity in death

Leave your comment


  • Maximum characters allowed: 5000
  • Simple HTML allowed: bold, italic, and links

Registration is quick and easy. Plus you won’t have to re-type the blurry words to comment!
Register | Login

  1. #1 Freweini Ghebresadick 22 Oct 13

    Your tragic death away from home and in the middle of unfamiliar places makes my heart bleed, my brothers and sisters. Your siblings, Eritrea's youth before you, gave their precious and innocent lives so that you would live in Freedom and without fear in your own country. What went wrong? What went wrong is Eritreans empowered demons like PFDJ, and for that, they cannot even save their sons' and daughters' lives. That is the story.

  2. #2 MESGNA BEYENE 23 Oct 13


  3. #3 Venesse 23 Oct 13

    Its the worst sadness i have ever felt in my life! Why must human beings be so suppressed by the leaders of their countries? It must stop nou!!! These Eritreans are living in one the worst countries in the world!!! I love these people, they are the loveliest people i have ever met, hardworking and the only desire they have is for their families to be fed and safe!!

  4. #4 Melake Ogbansae Mekal 23 Oct 13

    I felt very sad. This is not the first time for Eritreans, we have lost our family members,our beloved friends, our relatives , .... the list is endless please. I don't know what to say really I am really sad.
    May God rest them all in peace.

  5. #5 ezanamiki 23 Oct 13

    ya allahe

  6. #8 Fatma 23 Oct 13

    Oh, my brothers and sisters hemaq rakibkoum... when is this gonna stop??? always Eritrean youth suffer every where... ya Allah please have mercy on our people.. you are all knower and hearer please have mercy on our people and bring the peace to our land that stop this tragedy and gather all our youth like before.. Ameen!!

  7. #9 tadesse shiferaw 25 Oct 13

    እግዚአብሄር ያፅናችሁ--- ለፀፃነትም ያብቃችሁ፡፡

  8. #10 AL 25 Oct 13

    Why can't Italy, and many other developed countries adopt immigration laws similar to Canada and the USA. For example- a six months temporary resident visa for work, study or visiting family/ tourism. Medium and Long term/Permanent resident visas for various categories of migrants; economic, skilled, artisans by quota. Is there any immgration policy at all which recognises that Here is a reversal of 'peoples travelling to other lands seeking good fortune' that was the movement of colonialism. This may be part of the solution to ending this sad turn of the tides. And what about ships?

  9. #11 maris eri boy 27 Oct 13

    special thanks to Italian govt. for collecting those victims burying and conducting funeral ceremonies in respect with great care and humanity.
    May God allows the victims to inherit his paradise and give consolation to thei relatives and to the people of Eritrea in general!!!

  10. #12 Rochelle 28 Oct 13

    My condolences to the bereaved.

    Thank you for highlighting this tragic story.

  11. #13 Eshet 05 Mar 14

    Im very sad for deads of my brothers&sisters

Subscribe to Comments for this articleArticle Comment Feed RSS 2.0

Guidelines: Please be respectful of others when posting your reply.

Get our free fortnightly eNews


Videos from visionOntv’s globalviews channel.

Related articles

Recently in Web exclusives

All Web exclusives

Popular tags

All tags

New Internationalist Magazine Issue 436

If you would like to know something about what's actually going on, rather than what people would like you to think was going on, then read the New Internationalist.

– Emma Thompson –

A subscription to suit you

Save money with a digital subscription. Give a gift subscription that will last all year. Or get yourself a free trial to New Internationalist. See our choice of offers.