New Internationalist

John Pilger: Australia’s silent apartheid

November 2013

Hazel Healy talks to the trailblazing documentary filmmaker and investigative journalist about heroes, home and a mostly silent apartheid.

John Pilger [Related Image]
John Pilger

What’s your earliest memory?

Having my photograph taken with my brother Graham at the age of three. We were playing on the cold sand at Patonga on the banks of the Hawkesbury River near Sydney. He was instructing me, as older brothers do, to look at the camera and smile, and I was resisting. I had happy childhood moments there. It was many years before I learned that all around us was a secret battleground where the first Australians had fought the invading British. No-one talked about it – then and now.

Who inspires you?

I wrote a book called Heroes. The heroes were ordinary people who manage to survive and sometimes triumph against great political forces ranged against them. They inspire me.

What political issue are you most passionate about at the moment?

I’m not sure it’s possible to box ‘political passions’. Politics are part of life itself. Lately, I have been consumed by the making of Utopia, my film about the struggles and resistance of indigenous Australians. This is both an Australian story and a universal ‘issue’ – it’s about people defending a way of life against rapacious power, and having the right to share the riches and opportunities in their own country. It’s also about an apartheid that seldom speaks its name.

Utopia reunites you with people you filmed in The Secret Country in 1985. What had changed for them in the intervening years?

The short answer is, in essence, very little. A couple of examples: in the 1985 film I reported that in New South Wales almost a quarter of Aboriginal males who survived to the age of 20 were dead by 40. The latest statistics show that almost a third of Aboriginal people are dead before the age of 45 and almost half don’t live past 55. In 1985, I highlighted the fact that trachoma, which causes blindness and is entirely preventable, was rampant in indigenous communities. In Utopia, I point out that Australia is still on an international ‘shame list’ as the only first-world country that has not eradicated it. Almost all the victims are indigenous.

What has changed is the willingness of many indigenous Australians to fight back.

This is your fourth film about indigenous Australia. What inspired you to go back now?

I have been going back to Australia since I left. I’ve made seven films from and about my homeland; I’ve probably seen more of Australia than the great majority of my compatriots who sometimes give them impression of being bystanders in their own country. What inspires me to go back? Because there are two unique features about Australia: the ancient land and the original people. I am fortunate to have been born and to grow up in this haunting epic place, though I was not aware of that until, ironically, I returned from the other side of the world to ‘discover’ my own country.

In the film you reveal that indigenous children are being removed from their families at twice the rate as during the 20th century. Is this the Stolen Generation, all over again?

Yes, but with one major difference. The children of the first Stolen Generation were removed by welfare officials and others in authority, often for openly racist reasons: to ‘save’ Aboriginal children from their own societies: as the Chief Protector himself remarked famously, to ‘breed out the black’. Although the undeclared policy today is assimilation, the reasons given for removing children are often a form of blame – blame of indigenous families for their impoverishment and blame for the legacies of discrimination against them.

What needs to happen for the lot of first peoples in Australia to be transformed for the better?

Aboriginal people first and foremost should decide how their ‘lot’ is changed. At present, they are barely consulted. There will be a transformation only when they can sit down with the non-indigenous population and negotiate, as equals, a charter of rights that share the resources and opportunities of one of the world’s richest countries. It would not be difficult to achieve if the political will was there in Canberra [the seat of government]. It would be a transforming start, because it would exemplify something that is utterly absent – goodwill on the part of the majority.

In a recent piece in The Guardian, you wrote that ‘only Aboriginal people are the true Australians. The rest of us – beginning with Captain Cook – are boat people.’ Do you come under attack for these views when you travel back to your native Australia?

Yes: by those who themselves are part of the problem. The truth can be upsetting.

Where do you feel most at home?

I feel most at home in Australia, and most at home in London, and most at home in other parts of the world that have become familiar to me. I suppose I am an internationalist, but I am also very sentimental about those places where I ‘feel’ at home.

UTOPIA is in cinemas from 15 November with a Nationwide Q&A with John Pilger on Monday 18 November at Picturehouse Cinemas. Available on DVD from 2 December.

Front cover of New Internationalist magazine, issue 467 This column was published in the November 2013 issue of New Internationalist. To read more, buy this issue or subscribe.

Comments on John Pilger: Australia's silent apartheid

Leave your comment


  • Maximum characters allowed: 5000
  • Simple HTML allowed: bold, italic, and links

Registration is quick and easy. Plus you won’t have to re-type the blurry words to comment!
Register | Login

  1. #1 John Hart 04 Nov 13

    You are, indeed, a very honest Australian, John. This will be a surprise to most people. The apartheid has been kept a well-guarded secret.

  2. #2 William Mackie 06 Nov 13

    I haven't seen the film yet, but I was impressed by your book 'Secret Country'. It is a message that has to be repeated, especially now, with people like Abbott and Barnett in power.


  3. #3 Richard Brinkman 07 Nov 13

    You won't read about this in the Murdoch Press.

Subscribe to Comments for this articleArticle Comment Feed RSS 2.0

Guidelines: Please be respectful of others when posting your reply.

Get our free fortnightly eNews


Videos from visionOntv’s globalviews channel.

Related articles

Recently in And finally...

All And finally...

Popular tags

All tags

This article was originally published in issue 467

New Internationalist Magazine issue 467
Issue 467

More articles from this issue

  • Country Profile: Bolivia

    November 1, 2013

    A flourishing economy, more jobs and less poverty - is Bolivia a Latin American success story?

  • Mandela, my hero!

    November 1, 2013

    The current 'beatification' of Mandela is an attempt to neutralize his political legacy, says Steve Parry.

  • Our land, our freedom

    November 1, 2013

    Rural communities in Spain are reclaiming their farmland. Pablo Rabasco reports.

New Internationalist Magazine Issue 436

If you would like to know something about what's actually going on, rather than what people would like you to think was going on, then read the New Internationalist.

– Emma Thompson –

A subscription to suit you

Save money with a digital subscription. Give a gift subscription that will last all year. Or get yourself a free trial to New Internationalist. See our choice of offers.