New Internationalist

Venezuela - watch out!

A row has erupted over the latest Human Rights Watch report on Venezuela. Entitled A Decade Under Chávez, the report condemns 'political intolerance and lost opportunities for advancing human rights'.

A furious open letter quickly followed from more than 100 academic and other experts on Latin America. They accuse Human Rights Watch of naked political bias and, more seriously, of failing to do its homework. The report, they say, relies on secondary material gleaned from the partisan and notoriously unreliable local media, including an unhinged blogger.

After reading the report, I can see what they mean. I visited the country in 2006 to research a magazine for New Internationalist. I came away both inspired by what ordinary Venezuelans were achieving and a little worried by the reliance of the 'Bolivarian Revolution' on the figure of Chávez himself.

On the political front, the most striking thing was the utter hopelessness of the opposition - seemingly so conditioned by the power it had lost that it couldn't be bothered with anything other than the overthrow of the government by whatever means possible. My feeling was that they were, in their own way, as responsible as Chávez and his followers for their excesses.

So, quite apart from the damage such a disreputable piece of work does to human rights organizations in general, it's sad indeed to find Human Rights Watch falling into much the same trap, which can only make matters worse. That can’t possibly be on purpose - can  it?

Comments on Venezuela - watch out!

Leave your comment


  • Maximum characters allowed: 5000
  • Simple HTML allowed: bold, italic, and links

Registration is quick and easy. Plus you won’t have to re-type the blurry words to comment!
Register | Login

  1. #1 Phillip Smith 22 Dec 08

    Many thanks for pointing to the report David. I'm hoping to visit Venezuela again next year as part of broader travels in South America. I'm anxious to see what the state of the 'Bolivarian Revolution' is, in light of economic uncertainty and all that 2009 has yet to bring.


Subscribe to Comments for this articleArticle Comment Feed RSS 2.0

Guidelines: Please be respectful of others when posting your reply.

About the author

David Ransom a New Internationalist contributor

David Ransom joined New Internationalist in 1989 and wrote on a range of issues, from green justice to the current financial crisis, before retiring in 2009. He was a close friend of Blair Peach, once worked as a banker in Uruguay and continued to contribute to New Internationalist as a freelancer until shortly before his death in February 2016. He lived on a barge on the waterways of England’s West Country.

His publications include License to Kill on the death of Blair Peach in 1979 and The No Nonsense Guide to Fair Trade. He also co-edited, with Vanessa Baird, People First Economics.

Read more by David Ransom

Get our free fortnightly eNews


Videos from visionOntv’s globalviews channel.

Related articles

Popular tags

All tags

The Editors’ Blog

Provides the latest news, opinion and analysis from the NI editorial team as well as from our regular contributors and guest bloggers.

The Editors’ Blog