Act now to defend public education
In most countries we still take for granted that there is a public education system which provides for the majority of children. There has always been a small elite who perpetuate their privilege by sending their children to exclusive private schools for high fees. But in recent years we have seen the emergence of private schools that target the middle class. Pearson, the largest education company in the world, has spent hundreds of millions of dollars to purchase chains of such schools in India, Brazil and South Africa. And most recently there is the new phenomenon of what should be called ‘for-profit low-quality private schools’, touted by The Economist as the solution to expanding education provision in developing countries.
Except this is a lie. Low-fee private schools do not extend access to any of the 58 million children out of school around the world. Rather, they attract children (especially boys) who are already in government schools, whose parents can afford to pay for what they see to be an advantage. The effect is actively to undermine government schools (as their funding is often based on the number of children enrolled). And the children who go to these low-cost private schools do not actually get a better education. When controlled for socio-economic status, you find that the same children would have done just as well staying in the public education system. Basically, it is a clever con that exploits people’s aspirations. You attract the students who will do well anyway, and then claim that your school has made the difference.
Just 15 years ago there was a sustained campaign for the abolition of user fees in primary education. Research at that time showed that under the influence of the World Bank over 92 countries were charging children to go to primary school – often just a few dollars a month but enough to make schools inaccessible to the poorest children. Successful national campaigns led to the abolition in fees in countries such as Kenya, Burundi, Malawi and Ghana. In Kenya alone, over two million children enrolled in school the following year – children who could not afford to go to school before. In the light of this, it is patently nonsense that privatization can help make progress towards the goal of universalizing access to basic education.
Nor do such schools help to improve quality. It is widely recognized that the biggest determinant of quality learning is the quality of teachers. But these schools make their profit by employing untrained people as teachers, paying them less than a third of a professional teacher’s salary. Creating a cheap labour-force is not going to improve learning outcomes.
Now is the time to act, because there are aggressive forces pushing the privatization of education. New commercial chains of for-profit schools like Bridge International are being funded to expand in Africa by hedge-fund speculators and US billionaires – with just this one company planning to open a new school every three days (the larger the scale of operations the lower the unit costs). This is driven by greed and ideology, not by evidence – and it needs to be stopped. Strict government regulation of the private-sector providers is part of the solution, and some progress is being made on this with the support of the UN Special Rapporteur on the Right to Education.
But we also need to challenge those who are using public money to support such privatization. Three recent reports show that Britain’s Department for International Development (DFID) is increasingly channelling its public funding to support the privatization of education around the world. This is contributing to mounting violations of the right to education, increasing discrimination and undermining the huge potential of education to be an equalizing or transformative force.
We know how to improve public education – there are no great mysteries about it. We need well-financed public education systems that employ well-trained teachers working with manageable class sizes in accountable schools. Decades of IMF-enforced austerity have undermined people’s confidence that public education can be well financed. But recent work on tax justice shows that by removing harmful tax incentives and challenging aggressive tax avoidance over $200 billion could be generated every year. That is five times more than is needed in extra resources to guarantee quality public education for every child in every country. Quality public education, free at the point of use, is affordable – but unless we act now to defend it we will find that this simple foundation of a just society has been stripped away.
Take action against the privatization of education: globaljustice.org.uk/education
This blog has been crossposted with permission from Global Justice Now.
Help us keep this site free for all
New Internationalist is a lifeline for activists, campaigners and readers who value independent journalism. Please support us with a small recurring donation so we can keep it free to read online.