New Internationalist

Fortnum & Mason convictions are unacceptable assault on protest

In Courtroom 7 of Westminster Magistrates Court on Thursday, I joined many others convicted
so far this year for protesting against unjust austerity measures. For my protest, I walked into a shop and sat on the floor. It just so happened that this shop was Fortnum & Mason’s – the Queen’s grocer – and owned by a company guilty of millions of pounds worth of tax avoidance.

District Judge Snow ruled that by failing to leave the Queen’s corner-shop while others behaved in an intimidating manner, we were guilty of what the law terms ‘joint enterprise’.

The broader implications of this ruling are simply that anyone who is present when a crime is committed, and who doesn’t actively disassociate themselves from that crime, is liable to be considered equally culpable.

When I thought about this, after the ruling, a number of other ‘joint enterprises’ came to mind.

In 2008, the Lehman Brothers collapse plunged the global economy into a recession that has brought entire countries to bankruptcy, sparked the destruction of public services, and left millions world wide jobless, homeless and disenfranchised. But the financial services sector still trundles along seemingly oblivious.

As my co-defendant Adam Ramsay has pointed out, previously when banks have caused recessions, heads have rolled (metaphorically speaking) – but not on this occasion. The scale of the prosecution this time would be astronomical. By the same logic that informed the judgement that we received on Thursday morning, anyone at a bank who traded in the bundles of toxic loans known as collateralized debt obligations, is potentially guilty of causing the financial crisis through ‘joint enterprise’.

Next year PC Simon Harwood will face trial for manslaughter over assaulting Ian Tomlinson during the G20 protests in 2009. By the same logic that we were found guilty for the acts of others, any police officer present when Ian Tomlinson was assualted by PC Simon Harwood, by not disassociating themselves from the policing of the protest, is equally to blame for his death.

In the digital age, actions such as the Fortnum & Mason’s occupation, are increasingly organised over Facebook or Twitter. If you attend one of these events and someone does something illegal, the Fortnum ruling says that you can be arrested and convicted for not leaving the scene immediately.

The government and the police have, over the last 20 years or so, been ramping up a policy of criminalizing protest. They no longer see it as their role to facilitate protest in a democratic society. Instead they see their role as one of regulation, control and suppression.

This new interpretation of the law could see many hundreds more arrests and convictions of people whose only crime is to attend a protest and many thousands more intimidated into keeping their mouths shut. There is only one way to challenge this and it is not in the courtrooms, but on the streets.

Comments on Fortnum & Mason convictions are unacceptable assault on protest

Leave your comment


  • Maximum characters allowed: 5000
  • Simple HTML allowed: bold, italic, and links

Registration is quick and easy. Plus you won’t have to re-type the blurry words to comment!
Register | Login

  1. #1 jim 18 Nov 11

    ’The government and the police have, over the last 20 years or so, been ramping up a policy of criminalizing protest. They no longer see it as their role to facilitate protest in a democratic society. Instead they see their role as one of regulation, control and suppression.’

    Well, it's gotten worse over the last few decades, but it's nothing new. Any pretence of ’facilitating protest’ only lasts until we become a threat to their power... There never was a golden age of democracy and enlightened policing; they have always been a tool of the rich and powerful.

  2. #2 Rosemarie Leclerc 19 Nov 11

    The police and CPS are increasingly using the common law doctrine of Joint Enterprise - it is not just for ’gang crimes’ such as murder and allows for groups to all be convicted of the ’index offence’ and sentenced accordingly. You can find more about Joint Enterprise by googling JENGbA (Joint Enterprise: Not Guilty by Association)

  3. #3 Louise 20 Nov 11

    There is a select committee presently debating the 'joint enterprise' law (Rt Hon Sir Alan Beith MP, House of Commons) needless to say most authorities do not want it changed only slightly adjusted in order to continue criminalising anyone even if they are only standing by. There is a group called Jengba which is campaigning to change the law and stop its indiscriminate use - you can just google 'joint enterprise' and find it. It needs as much support as possible. This needs a strong voice.

  4. #4 Jay 21 Nov 11

    Joint Enterprise is a court full of lies and has been convicting innocent people for a long time. In recent years it has got seriously out of contol and the courts have become very arrogant and confident in this blanket scoop up convict all mentality. The biggest joint enterprise is the police, the CPS and the Judges and the MOJ for allowing this disgusting abuse of power to continue to the detriment of the innocent unsuspecting public. JENGbA is a campaign group that has been tirelessly addressing this legal principle for just over a year now. The lie that is Joint Enterprise must be made public and those in power must be made to address this abuse of the law and take serious action.Innocent people should not be criminalised. Can I point out another couple of JE's, the MP's expense scandal, and the phone hacking scandal....

Subscribe to Comments for this articleArticle Comment Feed RSS 2.0

Guidelines: Please be respectful of others when posting your reply.

About the author

Pete Speller a New Internationalist contributor

Pete Speller is a video journalist, blogger and campaigner based in Oxford, UK. He works developing video and technology support for protests and justice movements, such as with the group Students for a Free Tibet where he worked supporting citizen journalists in Beijing during the 2008 Olympics.

Read more by Pete Speller

Get our free fortnightly eNews


Videos from visionOntv’s globalviews channel.

Related articles

Popular tags

All tags

New Internationalist Blogs

New Internationalist hosts several different blogs, from the Editor's Blog to the Majority World Blog, the Gaza Blog to the Books Blog

New Internationalist Blogs