New Internationalist

Extremism’ film is racist war propaganda

The latest Bars for Change film has got it wrong by focusing on Muslim extremism in the UK, argues Jody McIntyre, who wants to dissociate himself from it.

The EDL have been portrayed as a group trying to ‘peacefully protest.’
Photo by Gavin Lynn under a CC Licence.

I agreed to be involved with the Bars for Change films [a Channel 4 series of online music documentaries] with the intent of giving a voice to young people who find themselves marginalised, discriminated against and ignored. Unfortunately, I spent the duration of the project battling against a television production company, Windfall Films, spearheaded by series producer Christian Broadhurst, intent on pursuing an elitist agenda. This ideology was revealed in the third film they have released which amounts to little more than a piece of pro-government war propaganda.

‘If it wasn’t for the Muslims Against Crusades,’ said Broadhurst, on the eve of the film’s release, ‘then the English Defence League wouldn’t exist.’ Broadhurst is the producer of the film, and even after the online backlash, he told me he was ‘editorially, completely happy’ with it.

He has spent the last few weeks filming with the EDL, but footage in the film of them beating up two Muslim youths is darkened out.  Instead, we see the following message:

‘The EDL claim to be non violent.  But violence seems to follow them.’

Violence is portrayed as an unwanted guest, tailing the EDL everywhere they go, rather than an act voluntarily and willingly being carried out on the screen in front of us. In the very next shot, as if to counter this already half-hearted suggestion of violence, we see the co-founder of the EDL urging members to protest peacefully. How sweet of him.

In reality, Windfall Films have not tried very hard to disguise the agenda behind this film. The very first text we see on screen begins with, ‘According to the government.’ So much for the tag line ‘your voice, your opinion’ that was supposed to define this series. In addition, the film was, before being forced offline by a unified online response, listed on YouTube in the ‘Non-Profit and Activism’ category, despite Windfall Films being a corporate television production company being paid a large amount of money to produce the series.

Windfall Films consistently failed to faithfully represent the musicians and performers on board with the Bars for Change series.  Black The Ripper was instructed to change his lyrics for the film, but refused to do so. ‘Sanna,’ who is actually Yemeni poet Sanasino and whose name they didn’t even bother to spell correctly, was lied to about the topic of the film and not told what footage of her would appear in the final cut. Producers originally told her the film was about ‘the dangers of far right extremism’ rather than extremism in general.

From recent conversations with people involved in the film, including Black The Ripper, Sanasino and SBTV, as well as my own numerous experiences, I worry that Christian Broadhurst has made a career out of tricking his way to a final product.  This manner of dealing with people, with so little respect, always results in negative consequences.

It is not only Sanasino whose footage was not included. Other key scenes were also glaringly absent. At the height of the student movement, Windfall Films recorded me interviewing Vince Cable MP, but no one has seen it since.  For episode two of Bars For Change, I conducted an interview with Sayid Javid MP. Where is that footage?  And where’s the footage of my interview with Stephen Lennon, founder of the English Defence League?

These interviews were intended to challenge those in power and celebrate the strength of our culture.  Not to act as Windfall Films’ mouthpiece for the government.

Comments on 'Extremism' film is racist war propaganda

Leave your comment


  • Maximum characters allowed: 5000
  • Simple HTML allowed: bold, italic, and links

Registration is quick and easy. Plus you won’t have to re-type the blurry words to comment!
Register | Login

  1. #1 pounce 06 Sep 11

    Jody McIntyre wrote:
    <i>’‘If it wasn’t for the Muslims Against Crusades,’ said Christian Broadhurst, on the eve of the film’s release, ‘then the English Defence League wouldn’t exist.’ Broadhurst is the producer of the film, and even after the online backlash, he told me he was ‘editorially, completely happy’ with it.</b>

    Mr Mcintyre,
    Are you saying that the above isn't true? If not, you be so kind as to inform the rest of us, just what single event crystallized British public opinion into forming the odious EDL.

    Just for your info the equally odious 'Muslims Against Crusades' are going to hold another stunt outside the American embassy on Sunday. This time they will be holding a noisy protest during the minutes silence for the people who were murdered on 11th September 2001.

  2. #2 Anindya Bhattacharyya 06 Sep 11

    I've been helping out with press enquiries for Unite Against Fascism in the run-up to Saturday's anti-EDL demo in Tower Hamlets. I had a phone call from this Christian guy about a month ago.

    He wanted UAF to provide him with an anti-racist teenager from Barking to conduct an ’interview’ about ’extremism’ with some EDL youth leader they'd dredged up.

    I explained to him that UAF didn't agree with giving platforms to fascists and wasn't interested in this kind of stunt. I told him that we were an anti-fascist campaign aimed at politically defeating the EDL, not at having polite chin-wags with them.

    He was very persistent. I eventually told him that if he wanted to interview a teenager from Barking who'd campaigned against the BNP and EDL, we'd put him in touch with someone - but we weren't interested in some kind of staged confrontation with the EDL. Seems I was right to smell a rat: he never called back.

  3. #3 Peace Activist 14 Sep 11

    I can only express my feelings against the EDL and those similar. These louts have seized the opportunity to move from football hooliganism towards racist hooliganism. Their actions have no moral worth what so ever. They should be subject to the same degree of punishment as any Muslim would be if found breaking the law. Whilst some may argue that others may have behaved badly; these yobbos have eagerly rushed to make this an excuse for yob culture. If Muslims appear on the streets to demonstrate they are in grave danger of being labeled 'terrorists'.

  4. #4 Ian Duncan 18 Oct 11

    Dear Jody,

    I’ve been meaning to write to you for a while about your blog in the New Internationalist.

    We are proud of Bars For Change and stand by all the films editorially - as does Channel 4. What you say about our film on extremism is not true, but what particularly disappoints me is the personal nature of your attack on the series producer Christian Broadhurst. This is potentially libellous – particularly your comments about him in the first edition of your article. We considered taking legal action, but decided it wasn’t worth wasting anymore of our time on the matter.

    Yours sincerely,

    Ian Duncan
    Executive Producer
    Bars For Change
    Windfall Films

Subscribe to Comments for this articleArticle Comment Feed RSS 2.0

Guidelines: Please be respectful of others when posting your reply.

About the author

Jody McIntyre a New Internationalist contributor

Jody McIntyre is a writer, poet, political activist and founder of The Equality Movement. He blogs at Life on Wheels.

Read more by Jody McIntyre

Get our free fortnightly eNews


Videos from visionOntv’s globalviews channel.

Related articles

Popular tags

All tags

New Internationalist Blogs

New Internationalist hosts several different blogs, from the Editor's Blog to the Majority World Blog, the Gaza Blog to the Books Blog

New Internationalist Blogs