New Internationalist

Brave Father Musala

April 2014

When a priest raised the alarm about rampant sex abuse in the Catholic Church in Uganda, he was sacked and accused of being gay. Patience Akumu caught up with him in Kampala.

Father Musala [Related Image]
‘Injustice must be resisted,’ insists Father Musala. © redpepper.co.ug

Father Anthony Musala waltzed into Uganda from England, where he was ordained, with change up his sleeves. When the Irish national of Ugandan origin released a music video in which he danced with abandon in his priestly robes, he dazzled and shocked conservative African Catholics.

‘It was something they had never seen,’ Musala, now 57, recalls. ‘A priest was supposed to be quiet.’

At first, he pulled crowds with his dashing celebrations of mass, his passionate and compassionate preaching and use of lively music. But there was an uncomfortable undercurrent. In a country of unbridled homophobia, Musala welcomed gay people to his church. He dared to speak openly about sexual abuse of boys and girls by Catholic priests who he said kept secret wives and children. As a confessor and counsellor, he knew how prevalent it was.

Last year, Musala wrote to the Archbishop of Kampala, Cyprian Lwanga, asking him to investigate sexual abuse and warning that the issue threatened to blow up in Uganda as it had in Europe. He also advised that the Catholic Church revise the rules on celibacy.

The authorities reacted by suspending him indefinitely and accusing him of homosexuality. The Archbishop said that the priest’s letter was threatening the morality of the Church and its followers. But Musala maintains that the Church, like the State, is using homosexuality as a diversionary tactic in order not to tackle the issue of clerical sex abuse.

‘They are promoting injustice. They do not know what it means to be abused,’ he adds, referring to his experience of molestation, aged 16, in a Catholic school. ‘There is hostility towards victims whenever they come out.’

‘I am an African. I belong here’

Still, many lauded Musala for his brave revelations, hoping it would lead to a proper investigation. But allegations about Musala’s sexuality soon took centre stage.

‘They asked me on television if I am gay – in a country that wants to imprison gay people for life.’

Like many countries in Africa, Uganda clings to old British colonial laws criminalizing homosexuality, but a new law has increased penalties. Passed last December, it was presented in parliament as a ‘Christmas present’ to the populace. At first, the Catholic Church in Uganda had not supported the bill, saying it went against Catholic teaching. But later, together with the Orthodox and Anglican Church, it endorsed it.

US evangelists further fanned the anti-gay flames. It was they, according to Musala, who first sowed the seeds of homophobia in the country after a lesbian wedding in Wandegeya – a small Ugandan town known for a robust night life – in 1999.

‘Two women held a ceremony. They moved on to the street and people were fascinated. They were curious. They were not homophobic like they are today.’

But it was not all innocent curiosity. Solomon Male and Martin Ssempa, renowned anti-gay pastors, approached the media, saying that the ‘gay agenda’ was out to destroy Africa.

Abuse in the Catholic Church

4,000 cases of child sex abuse involving Catholic clergy investigated by the Vatican between 2002 -12. (Daily Mail)

$3 billion paid out by US Catholic Church in settlements of sex abuse cases to date. (BishopAccountability.org)

4% of Catholic priests in the US sexually victimized minors in the past 50 years.* (Psychology Today)

*Comparable to other religions – and no higher than teachers or men in general. Catholics stand out for the extent of institutional silence and cover-up.

‘That is when they began to say that gay people were getting money from Americans; that they were sick and they needed help.’

Musala alleges that the subject of celibacy is particularly sensitive in Uganda because top Catholic leaders have sired children. He blames this on Africa’s culture of patriarchy that views women as no more than baby-making machines.

‘They feel like they too should get a woman to have a child with. It does not matter [to them] if she is under-age.’

The priest regrets that while the Church chooses to condemn some atrocities in the country, like the rampant violation of political rights, it metes out similar injustices itself.

Musala appealed to the Vatican against the decision to suspend him six months ago but received no reply.

In desperation, he travelled to London to ask the Archdiocese of Westminster, where he was ordained, to intervene. Or, at the very least, to provide him with employment, not necessarily as a priest, so he could meet his daily needs. The diocese would not get involved, fearing that any comments might prejudice the final decision at the Vatican.

‘There is a deep tradition of silence in the church. Westminster could not speak out, even if what the Catholic Church in Uganda is doing would not be allowed in England,’ he says. ‘In England they were forced to speak only because the church was sued for similar violations.’

Musala returned to Uganda but his quest for justice has left him weary and uncertain, a shadow of his old enthusiastic self.

‘I do not know where to go. I do not know what to do. Do you think the civil courts can help me?’ he asks.

But he is not daunted. Not even by Ugandans who dismiss his criticisms as evidence of foreign influence.

‘Injustice must be resisted. I am African. I belong here.’

Malicious, underhand and sinister

Father Patrick Lawson is a Scottish Catholic priest who has fought for 17 years to get the Church hierarchy to take action against a fellow priest who sexually abused him. But when he went to the press revealing that the parish priest in question abused altar boys and also made sexual advances when he was a seminarian, Lawson was dismissed by the Catholic hierarchy. Parishioners were furious. More than 200 signed a petition asking for the popular hard-working cleric’s reinstatement. And there was support from other priests. Father Gerard Magee wrote to the papal nuncio in London, backing Father Lawson and criticizing the diocese. ‘What they are doing is underhand, malicious and sinister,’ he wrote. Father Lawson’s removal, he believes, is punishment for going public. ‘They’re trying to get rid of him because he’s a whistleblower. A lot of priests don’t like him because he spoke out. I don’t understand why some priests are more intent on protecting the criminal rather than the victim.’

Father Lawson is suing for wrongful dismissal.

Source: Observer September and December 2013

Patience Akumu is an award-winning Ugandan journalist living in Kampala, specializing in social issues.

Front cover of New Internationalist magazine, issue 471 This feature was published in the April 2014 issue of New Internationalist. To read more, buy this issue or subscribe.

Comments on Brave Father Musala

Leave your comment