New Internationalist

Holy Hatred

Issue 328

Click here to subscribe to the print edition. [image, unknown] New Internationalist 328[image, unknown] [image, unknown] [image, unknown] October 2000[image, unknown] Click here to search the mega index.

Sexual Minorities / INTOLERANCE

Holy Hatred
Penalties for homosexuality are most extreme
in Muslim countries. Anissa Hélie looks at what's
behind the current drive to control sexuality.

I was born and raised in Algiers, of a French father and an Algerian mother. Having access to both cultures made me realize early on that racism as well as sexism were all-pervasive on both sides of the Mediterranean. It took me a few more years to come to the conclusion that homophobia was just as widespread.

Amnesty International counts at least 83 countries where homosexuality is explicitly condemned in the criminal code.1 Twenty-six of these are Muslim. This means that the majority of Muslim countries, including supposedly 'liberal' ones like Tunisia as well as dictatorships like Sudan, outlaw same-sex relationships.

The seven countries in the world that carry the death penalty for persons presumed guilty of homosexual acts, justify this punishment with the Shari'a or standard interpretation of Muslim jurisprudence. Though not always applied, the existence of the death penalty makes sexual minorities extremely vulnerable.2

Sheikh Sharkhawy publicly advocates the execution of gay males over the age of 10 and life imprisonment for lesbians

The state is not alone in practising repression. Communities and families have a part to play. In Indonesia, for example, homosexuality is not illegal. But in 1998 'Muslim militia' launched an anti-gay campaign on the island of Mindanao during which gay Muslims were terrorized, beaten up and ordered to leave or be castrated.

Jordan does not specifically outlaw homosexuality either. But that did not stop four Jordanians last year trying to kidnap their 23-year-old lesbian relative studying in the US, beating her and attempting to force her on to a plane bound for Jordan. The US police acted promptly and came to her rescue, but such an outcome tends to be the exception rather than the rule. Violence, harassment, persecution and extrajudicial or 'shame' killings are not uncommon.

Sex and tradition
In spite of such obstacles and hostility, same-sex relationships do take place, even in the most repressive countries. As one researcher from the Gulf told a Pan-Arab Conference on Sexuality held in Oxford in June 2000: 'In prison same-sex sex is the norm. Saudi Arabia is just a large prison.'

Sometimes, the very segregation of the sexes allows for intimacy between people of the same gender without it being considered abnormal. As long as one keeps a low profile, such behaviour may generally go unchallenged. This is true for both sexes. For women, cultural patterns may allow particular opportunities for intimacy: it's fairly acceptable to share a bed with your female cousin, your best friend and so on. And traditional women-only ceremonies may actually enable rural lesbians to make regular contact with other women.

Culture is not, therefore, always against us and there are positive examples of same-sex relationships to be found in different Muslim cultures. Nor is invisibility necessarily required. For example, in some traditional travelling theatres and musical groups in Pakistan, the younger men who play female roles sometimes live as a couple with the group leader. Among such communities, male couples may live out love relationships quite openly. There is also an entire body of poetry in local and Urdu literature that is clearly based on male love, yaari.3

Positive as they are, such examples should not make us forget that homophobia is prevalent, as well as systematically promoted by conservative forces - everywhere.

Conservative manipulation
'The Qur'an clearly states that homosexuality is unjust, unnatural, transgression, ignorant, criminal and corrupt,' declares the Jamaat-e-Islami, an extreme right politico-religious party in Pakistan.4

In fact, the Qur'an is far from clear on the issue and the controversy regarding the position of Islam and homosexuality is ongoing. For some people, homosexuality is 'unlawful' in Islam; for others, the Qur'an does not clearly condemn homosexual acts.

The only actual reference to homosexuality in the Qur'an can be found in the sections about Sodom and Gomorrah. While the harsh punishment inflicted on the people of Sodom and Gomorrah at the time of the prophet Lut is for some people a clear proof that Allah meant to eradicate homosexual practice, others argue that there is no specific punishment for homosexuality. The people of Sodom were punished for 'doing everything excessively' and for not respecting the rules of hospitality. They insist that it is not the Qur'an itself that brings condemnation of homosexuals but rather the homophobic culture prevailing in Muslim societies.

In the vanguard of repression are so-called 'religious fundamentalists'. But in the Women Living Under Muslim Laws Network to which I belong, we maintain that 'fundamentalism' is not a return to the 'fundamentals' of any given religion. We believe that 'fundamentalists' are extreme-right political forces seeking to obtain or maintain political power through manipulation of religion and religious beliefs, as well as other ethnic, culturally-based identities. And the rise of 'fundamentalism' is a global phenomenon which affects not just Islam but all major religions.

There is also a strong connection between fundamentalist homophobic assaults and those directed against women who do not 'behave' - who may be unmarried or living alone. Extremist religious leaders and their followers target sexual minorities and women first. They focus their offensive against homosexuals as well as others who transgress boundaries of 'acceptable' behaviour. The very same rhetoric is used to justify repression against homosexuals, feminists or 'different' women - who all are systematically denounced as non-Muslim, non-indigenous and so forth. It is always through manipulation of religious, national or cultural identities that violence is legitimized.

Culture is not, therefore, always against us and there are positive examples of same-sex relationships to be found in different Muslim cultures

Both extremist religious leaders and state officials are likely to demonize sexual minorities, often as a means to distract from economic crisis or political controversy. Indeed, incitement to hatred and manifestations of homophobia increase in places where the local political agenda is most affected by growing fundamentalist forces.

For example, one of the very first victims of Algerian fundamentalists was Jean Sénac, a gay poet assassinated in the early 1980s. Also in Algeria, Oum Ali, an unmarried woman living alone with her children in the Southern town of Ouargla, was stoned and her house burned down in 1989, killing her youngest son.5 These two incidents occurred long before the 'official' beginning of the conflict; they reveal the untruth of Algerian fundamentalists' claims that they only resorted to violence in 1992 after being robbed of victory by the Government's cancellation of elections. In fact they targeted both homosexuals and women earlier on - but there was hardly anyone to stand up for such 'second-class victims'.

Joining forces
Why is sexuality and sexual conformity the focus of so much attention by fundamentalist forces? A possible answer is that when people exercise individual choice it appears as a challenge: autonomy - especially for women - is seen as a threat.

It is interesting to note that in past centuries Arabs attributed homosexual behaviour to the bad influence of Persians. Today, it's much the same story, though the characters may change - homosexuality is currently denounced as a 'Western disease'. In June 2000, Malaysian Foreign Minister Syed Hamid Albar stated that homosexuality was 'against nature' and - following a call by Human Rights Watch to ban Malaysia's sodomy law - insisted that: 'We can't amend the country's laws merely due to calls by outsiders'.

[image, unknown]

[image, unknown]

Al-Fatiha (meaning 'the Opening' or 'the Beginning' in Arabic) has branches in the US, Canada and UK. Recently held its second international conference.
Website: www.alfatiha.org

Kelma Belgium specifically supports North African gays and lesbians.
E-mail: kelmabelgique@hotmail.com

[image, unknown] Homan advocates for the rights of Iranian gays and lesbians; it has branches in Britain, US, Norway and Sweden and publishes a magazine (right) in both Persian and English.
Website: www.homan.cwc.net/

The Yoesuf Foundation in the Netherlands aims at providing information related to Islam and homosexuality.
E-mail: education@yoesuf.nl

Karama, based in the US, brings together sexual-minority Arabs, Armenians, Assyrians, Berbers, Persians and Turks.
E-mail: Karama-request@MIT.EDU

Assal (meaning 'honey') is an Arab lesbian support group in the US.
E-mail: labwas@yahoo.com

[image, unknown]

Not just a local or national phenomenon, fundamentalism has taken on a global dimension. Extremist religious leaders from various faiths are coming together to oppose sexual rights. By 'closing ranks', coalitions of Christians, Muslims and other fundamentalists affect the international agenda. We saw the effect of such alliances on women's reproductive rights at the Cairo Conference on Population and Development in 1994. Such alliances also blocked the recognition of the rights of lesbians at both the 1995 World Conference on Women held in Beijing and the review of the Beijing Platform for Action in June 2000.

Of course, similar coalitions influence local political agendas. Take Britain, a secular country with a very vocal extremist Muslim minority. A Muslim-Christian alliance was recently formed to oppose the repeal of Section 28 - a law introduced in 1988 which forbids the 'promotion' of homosexuality in schools as 'a pretended family relationship'. At a conference in May 2000, religious spokesperson Dr Majid Katme stated that 'lesbianism is spreading like fire in society. We must vaccinate our children against this curse'. He is supported in this view by Sheikh Sharkhawy - a senior cleric at the prestigious Regent's Park mosque in central London - who publicly advocates the execution of gay males over the age of ten and life imprisonment for lesbians.6

At least as worrying is the support for fundamentalist politics by the so-called 'free West'. The help extended by states pretending to defend democracy is not a new phenomenon. Imam Khomeini was resident in France for several months in 1978, just before going back to Iran to lead the 'Islamic' revolution. In Afghanistan, the CIA not only trained the Taliban but has also 'admitted bringing 25,000 Arab volunteers to fight. against the Red Army'.7 Incidentally, both those countries - Iran and Afghanistan - currently sentence homosexuals to death.

What does that teach us? First, that the hypocrisy of most political leaders knows no limit: their ever-changing definition of 'fundamentalism' allows them to turn against allies of yesterday with whom they should never have got involved in the first place. Second, it is obvious that economic and geo-strategic concerns always prevail. We can only regret that there are so few allies at the international level who are ready to compromise their interests in order to defend the rights of women and sexual minorities.

Strategies of resistance
Despite a threatening environment, sexual minorities are organizing and becoming more visible in Muslim countries and communities. For example, much research is being carried out to interpret religious texts. The Qur'an is being re-examined by gay, or gay-friendly, theologians and believers in order to break the monopoly of male homophobic interpretation. To counter the stereotype of homosexuality as foreign, others are engaged in reclaiming homoerotic literature.8

Another positive example is found in Lebanon, where homosexuality is illegal, but a popular weekly TV programme (Al Shater Yahki) has been focusing on sexuality since 1997 and includes gay voices. The fact that they speak from behind masks gives a measure of the risks involved.

Nevertheless, new solidarity associations are being set up (see above). These organizations are, for obvious security reasons, often located outside Muslim countries. Most of them, however, connect with either individuals or groups within Muslim countries. Whether mainly political, social or religious in their motivation, these organizations all aim at breaking the isolation faced by sexual minorities. In Muslim countries and communities, sexual minorities have only just begun speaking out. Threats of violence and accusations of betraying one's culture and religion have discouraged many from taking a public stand. However, more and more people are rejecting the idea that violence against sexual diversity is 'divinely sanctioned'.

[image, unknown] Anissa Hélie is a feminist and human-rights activist who has been involved in the
Women Living Under Muslim Laws International Solidarity Network for nearly 15 years.
For more information: http://wluml.org/ENGblurb.html
This article is based on a talk at the IGLHRC 'Separation of Faith and Hate' conference in Rome, July 2000.

1 Amnesty International Report 1998.
2
The death penalty exists in: Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Mauritania, Sudan, Yemen and Chechnya.
3 Sohail Akbar Warraich, 'A Walk on the Wild Side: Aspects of Homosexuality in Pakistan', She Magazine (March/April 2000).
4 Quote from the Jamaat-e-Islami from Pakistan, Al-Fatiha website.
5 Center for Women's Global Leadership, Testimonies of the Global Tribunal on Violations of Women's Human Rights (Vienna, June 1993).
6 Raza Griffiths, 'Hague and Young in pretend family relationship with religious right', Gay Times, May 2000.
7 Farhan Bokhari and David Gardner, 'Pakistan struggles with legacy of Afghan war', Financial Times 5 July 2000.
8 Examples include Sufi poet Jalaluddin Rumi, Ottoman 'divan literature' and Ismat Chughtai, twentieth-century woman writer from the Indian sub-continent.


Previous page.
Choose another issue of NI.
Go to the contents page.
Go to the NI home page.
Next page.


This first appeared in our award-winning magazine - to read more, subscribe from just £7

Comments on Holy Hatred

Leave your comment